Monday, 4 March 2013

Is feminism the dirty word today that feminine was to the modernists?


Tackling the new F word…
Today I was extremely lucky. I spent three hours (not all at once!) listening to four people talk about The Great Gatsby. I was busily taking notes (I do this at all lectures and most museums and galleries too just FYI- I love a good note) when the second speaker began talking about the issue of ‘the feminine’ to the modernist. He cited Fitzgerald, TS Eliot and Ezra Pound to name but a few and with painful accuracy quoted some of their more disparaging comments about ‘the feminine’.
In this instance the modernists were seen to promote so-called masculine qualities of pared-down narrative, emotion-free prose and simple style (big whoop) while simultaneously casting, often foul, judgement on the ‘feminine’ qualities of emotion and feeling. They saw this (no big surprise here) as a battle and themselves as fighters. They did not want to be popular with female readers as to be so was to be associated with the ‘trash’ that they read. In fact Ezra Pound in particular postured himself as having to save poetry from the trap associated with the popularity of poetry among a female readership-yes that’s correct women loved poetry and we all know exactly how low-brow Shakespeare, Donne, Browning, Keats and the gang were! His description of this battle is grotesque so excuse me quoting it here: writing good poetry was, he said, like ‘driving any new idea into the great passive vulva of [literary] London’. Cue gagging and heaving from the assembled crowd…
No.
A couple of titters at the word vulva. But nobody (apart from, very conspicuously, me) leapt forward in their seats gasping at such a vile presentation of women, literature and let’s face it London. Yet as I sat there guppy-like trying to recover my composure I began to feel more, rather than less, queasy. No one was freaking out because the crowd were reassured by the fact that the speaker had excused the quotation as ‘of its time’ and the crowd (largely female) smiled indulgently and were content to think that such a time had passed.
Thankfully it has to a great extent. We would find mercifully few writers today who would merrily use what is essentially a rape analogy, to present the experience of writing. There is also a greater than ever embrace of feminine qualities of emotion and empathy, more women in positions of political and economic power and a brace of excellent women writers and journalists who are finally speaking out and saying something meaningful about what it means to be a woman.
Yet something still rankles. Something doesn’t quite fit. Perhaps it is what I was referring to in my last post- do late-twenty-something men experience the same levels of judgement that we do? But I have a nagging suspicion that it goes beyond that. My fear is that Feminism is being used against us. We only need look back over the past two weeks to see evidence. Look at what happened to the genius that is Hilary Mantel who dared to make a comment about the horrifying treatment in the media of Kate Middleton and the bizarre nature of her role in the royal family. What she was saying was an extremely poignant and  admittedly uncomfortable and yet in one of the ugliest media attacks I have seen she was dubbed as ‘anti-feminist’ by many (largely those numpties who took everything she said out of context and decided she had been criticising Kate, while in fact she had been criticising the role of Princess throughout history) and those who simply decided that she was jealous that Kate was thinner and prettier than she was. Terrifying though such a s*** storm was for me, it was no surprise. It came in a month when Kristine Holmgren admitted that she was invited to write a blog for Beliefnet only to be told that she had to take the word ‘feminist’ from her proposed blog title as they were concerned about the ‘negative connotations’ associated with the word. February was also the month in which Naomi McAuliffe and Ellie Mae O’Hagan debated whether feminists should be funny or angry (an over simplification of an interesting argument but do forgive me for the purpose of speed and clarity) as there needed to be a clear pathway for feminists to be in order to successfully promote the cause.
As we slink out of the murky anti-feminist turmoil of February and March dawns with a ray of fragile hope I have taken the issue of the F-word to the masses (in the form of my book-club made up of 9 women who all have important careers, are aged between 26 and 45, three of whom are married, one is engaged, two have live in boyfriends and three are single) and I asked them if they would consider themselves to be feminist. A deathly silence fell. This was a group of women who have discussed literature, naturally, but also our own experiences  of sex, miscarriage, stress, depression, divorce and even death but yet this question utterly floored them. Once they had righted themselves from their Tweety-Pie at the bottom of the cage posture the answers were heart-breaking ranging from ‘I couldn’t get into that Caitlin Moran book so probably not’ to ‘ I thought I was but my friend is really militant about it so..’ and finally to ‘I really liked that Asda Christmas advert- you know the one where the mum does everything and it’s all worth it when she sits down and sees everyone happy- so I can’t be’.
Ladies what have we done to ourselves? We appear to have somehow allowed ourselves to be hung on our own rope. Perhaps what we need is not to convert people- men and women- to the feminist cause. Perhaps what we need is to ‘rebrand’ the cause itself. Perhaps we need to give it a new name. Or maybe we should just tell people who dare to use it against us to F-off.

No comments:

Post a Comment