Tuesday, 21 May 2013

Myths:What's the big deal


Readers I am writing in a state of breathless excitement from having just seen Baz Luhrman’s visual orgy: The Great Gatsby so forgive me if this post is slightly ‘modern’.
Having read Fitzgerald’s classic no fewer than fifteen times, I was always going to be apprehensive about watching a treatment of a piece of literature that has spoken to me in profound and surprising ways for the past decade. What if it was ‘ruined’ for me? So it was with a copy of the text in my pocket for comfort and a large Pinot G in my hand for courage, I donned my 3D glasses (cringe) and settled down to 142 minutes of visual splendour.
Was it true to the novel? In many ways of course the answer is no: the modern soundtrack and the decidedly MTV dance moves alone put paid to the authenticity of the 1920s experience. However, that said, it is true to the essence of the novel and has at its core the spirit of Fitzgerald’s novel: the idea that the when man and myth become confused, devastation is inevitable.
At the time of publication the idea of the myth of Gatsby was largely ignored by critics and readers who dismissed the novel as another, almost anecdotal, commentary on their environment. But it is this representation of self- mythologising that has arguable been responsible for its enduring popularity. In a world obsessed with myths, fantasy, romance and self-promotion it is not hard to understand why The Great Gatsby and the great Gatsby have seen a significant revival in recent times.
Considering the novel again in light of Luhrman’s romantic and, to coin Fitzgerald’s own phrase, orgiastic interpretation I couldn’t help but wonder whether I admired or was frightened of the character of Gatsby. Here is a man who was determined to prove something about himself to the world and to the woman he aspires to love, and so creates a version of himself from scratch, shedding his past, his name, his family in favour of an altogether shinier self.  Is that so terrible? Should we all not be able to move on, and if necessary, away from our pasts? Certainly I have heard friends, family, even myself say ‘that’s not who I am anymore’, ‘that was the old me,’ ‘I am doing a life laundry.’
In fact the success of TV makeover shows alone goes some way to prove that the appeal of being able to reinvent yourself is an enduring one. But what is the difference between a makeover and a myth-over? Why is one so attractive and even admirable, while the other one doomed to fail?
I propose the idea that a makeover involves an acceptance and an acknowledgement of your flaws, be they of the physical, personal or interior decorating kind, while a myth-over involves choosing an idea of something or someone that does not , and almost certainly cannot, exist in reality and presenting yourself as a manifestation of that concept.
There is no denying that there is an attraction to the modern mythical concepts. What girl doesn’t want to be the ‘cool girl’ from the romcoms (think Mila Kunis in Friends With Benefits: beautiful, quirky, great job, cool (huge) flat in New York, loves beer and football, never gets fat, does get nookie with Justin Trousersnake). The problem is though, is that if I tried to be that girl I would a) make myself sick b) have nothing in common with anyone else who is an actual human and c) would get found out.
Aye there’s the rub. You get found out. Daisy returns to Tom, I would argue not because she wants his status –she has plenty of her own- but because for all Tom’s myriad flaws and failings she knows him and the flaws as part of a whole person. Gatsby, on the other hand, exposes himself as an incomplete person, as a mythological creature in that hotel room and the unknown, the uncertain, and quite frankly the unreal, suddenly no longer seems exciting, but instead seems risky and precarious.
We have all been there: the guy who has a rockstar front but still lives with his mum at thirty; the friend with the super-flash lifestyle who resorts to selfies (word of the week: meaning photos you take of yourself) to show it off. Ultimately the myth will turn in on itself and will lead to pity rather than admiration and loneliness rather than social status.
My final thought is that we could all probably do with a little tweaking here and there, but we should learn from the Greeks- to buy into myths can result in terrible things; the onslaught of sin in the world; having your heart pecked out on a cliff; or an outfit malfunction so serious you plummet to your death- all for getting a little ahead of yourself.
Now where is that teeth-whitening toothpaste?

No comments:

Post a Comment